The opinions expressed by Entrepreneur authors are their very own.
A powerful patent can protect your inventions by deterring competition and quick imitators while increasing your market position. On the other hand, a weak patent may be a costly waste of effort for your team. It could have been too expose your organization to costly lawsuitsundermining your competitive advantage.
To draft a patent application, portfolio managers typically seek drafting recommendations for reputable corporations, balancing costs with quality expectations. However, determining design quality is difficult due to the complexity of patent language and legal jargon. A superb rule of thumb is that you just normally get what you pay for.
The purpose of this text is to simplify the situation and provide easy, practical suggestions for securing patents that work well and provide the most value to what you are promoting. Below are five checks to ensure high-quality patent applications:
1. Significant reach
The basis of a high-quality patent is its substantive scope. It’s not only about documenting your invention; it’s about providing comprehensive protection.
This requires not only a detailed description of the invention, including alternatives and embodiments, but also a strategy that makes it difficult for competitors to circumvent patent protection.
The key to achieving this is to thoroughly search and analyze the prior art of those with similar solutions to ensure that the patent clearly and conspicuously claims the invention. This step is essential to minimize the risk of infringement and increase the enforceability of the patent. You want claims that are broad, but not so broad that they are invalid.
Moreover, the use of forward-looking language that takes into account potential technological evolutions on the horizon increases the relevance and protection of the patent over time, future-proofing the patent.
2. Emphasis on the essence of innovation
The core innovation – what sets your invention apart – ought to be fastidiously described in your patent application.
This does not mean a transient mention; this implies pages of detailed evaluation of the invention’s unique features, potential applications, and technical specifications. The designer should explore the invention beyond the initial disclosure, adding depth and breadth to the application. There is at all times a core innovation that stands out from the crowd, called the heart of innovation, and extensive examination of this point is crucial to a broad and defensible patent application.
In some of the patent litigation cases I inherited from other authors, I used to be dissatisfied to see that they barely scratched the surface of what made the invention unique. The Patent Office wants a thorough explanation of the inner workings of the invention around the heart of the innovation. Approval of poorly drafted applications is one other area where excellent patent attorneys are invaluable.
To ensure your patent application hits the nail on the head, run it through the inventor and ask whether their invention is clearly and fully explained. Spend most of your time developing the most vital distinguishing features of the invention so that you just have many different alternatives and technical details.
3. Strategically constructed claims
The essence of every patent are the claims it comprises, which determine the limits of its protection. Only the claims define the scope of patent law, and the remainder of the draft application only provides context. Creating these claims requires a nuanced balance: it is too broad and risks rejection; too narrow and may not provide sufficient protection.
Start by comparing the claims with the disclosure to make sure nothing has been missed. This step may reveal missing elements that, when added, will increase your probabilities of receiving patent relief. Rewrite the claims, considering how the infringer could easily avoid them. They have multiple claims of various format and scope to block any competition which may want to design around them.
Given a 20-year patent term, it is vital that the technology it covers stays relevant for at least 10-15 years, adapting to changes in the industry. The goal is to prepare claims that prevent others from circumventing your patent, thereby closing potential loopholes. Include innovations still on the drafting board that may turn into vital in future years.
A practical tactic is to check for existing patents in your technology field. This step helps you understand the approach to claim construction. Such a review can provide key information needed to analyze the claims made in the application being evaluated. It also helps you identify your contribution to the area that ought to be claimed.
4. Technical and legal proficiency
A high-quality patent starts with a solid foundation each in the technical field of the invention and in the legal framework governing patentability. This proficiency is crucial because patent documents, with their convoluted legal jargon and complex technical descriptions, may be daunting.
Patent portfolio managers should seek help from specialists who not only excel in patent law but also have a deep understanding of the relevant technology. Their ability to translate the essence of an innovation into a legally sound document is what distinguishes a successful patent application from others. Few patent writers will admit to lacking experience, so look for someone who knows your technology.
Before contacting professionals, it is value preparing well. Check these out six things you must know before hiring a patent attorney!
5. Attention to detail
A patent is a legal document, not marketing material created by a copywriting genius. That’s why a strong patent application doesn’t draw back from delving deep into technical details.
A high-quality patent delves deeper into the mechanics of the invention, providing many fastidiously explained diagrams detailing the technology in terms of the problems it solves. Visual aids similar to diagrams and screenshots help illustrate complex concepts, making them more accessible and enhancing the comprehensiveness of the application.
Remember that a patent consisting of 10-15 digits explained in several dozen pages with clear descriptions often indicates a solid, well-thought-out application.
The path lies ahead
The use of experience is crucial to achieving high-quality patent applications. The wisdom gained from previous submissions, each successes and lessons learned, are invaluable. Patent portfolio managers can use this experience to refine their strategies for future applications.
An excellent patent application focuses on the key aspects that distinguish your predecessors from their predecessors and provides the required details so that others can create and use the invention based on this description. Having a great technical background for your product allows your draftsman to have the right description and numbers that clearly showcase your innovation now and in the future.
Additionally, staying up to date with the latest developments in patent law, technological innovations and industry changes is key to maintaining a robust and relevant patent portfolio.